Christoph Strawe: Initiative and Institution, Individual Action in the Community

Christophe Strawe

Initiative and Institution
Individual Action in Community

We live in a time when the relationship of the individual to the community is changing radically. The watchwords are individualization, pluralization and globalization. How should social structures change so that we can live freely, without fragmenting society through our egoistic interests? Usually we hear the answer that we need a threefold social organism, in which freedom and brotherhood are united on the basis of equal human rights. We encounter many considerations of what this means for the individual areas of community life – education, healthcare, property rights, and so on – and it is undoubtedly our constant task to raise awareness of the necessity of these changes and to look for ways to realize them in practice.
However, work on this level alone cannot bring satisfactory results. Knowing something or wanting it does not in itself make our social impulse viable in life. The social question cannot be solved once and for all, just as we cannot cook a meal that would satisfy us once and for all. People must seek its solution anew every time. Social structures can make this easier or harder for them, but they do nothing by themselves. Even the most social arrangement of a community will founder if the people within it behave antisocially.
The threefold social organism is therefore not a solution to the social question in itself, but only the creation of preconditions so that it can be solved again and again. The threefold order is meant to create space in society for initiative, for the emergence of new free communities. Such communities, based on initiative and responsibility, will gradually have to replace the old model of governance from above. Self-administration instead of state measures – this is the motto of modern social development.

Between Scylla and Charybdis

Let us take as an example the self-governing Waldorf school as a community based on the responsibility of parents and teachers – in the interest of the children. All self-governing institutions – unless self-government is taken merely formally – are such communities based on responsibility. (This of course also applies to all companies and other similar communities, in which the areas of responsibility are more varied and the levels of responsibility more graded than within the teachers' college.) This responsibility must not be understood merely as independence from the state or society, but must permeate the real life of the community. When this does not succeed, the community falls back into the old conditions that made the overcoming necessary. It is not enough to reject the power structures of the centralized state; it is also necessary to prevent the community itself from becoming a centralized state in miniature. And these tendencies must be prevented in their very beginnings.
Many self-governing institutions know this problem. Why – despite many positive "achievements" – is there so much dissatisfaction with social relations, for example, in anthroposophical facilities and in their surroundings? Often it is because the institution itself has come to the fore and pushed initiative into the background, so that a community in the old sense has arisen, based on subordination and adaptation to structures. Initiative is then mistakenly understood as arbitrariness. That is, as the usurpation of authority, regardless of the community. These are the Scylla and Charybdis between which the modern community must steer.
"Health exists only when the whole community forms itself in the mirror of the human soul, and when the power of the individual soul lives in the community." This is how Rudolf Steiner formulated the "motto of social ethics." It succinctly and aptly expresses the essence of the new community which – unlike communities of the old kind – rests entirely on freedom. If we take this motto seriously, we see two elements which alone can create a healthy modern community and which proceed from the individual: firstly, the reflection with which he perceives the shared task of children, clients, colleagues and so on; and secondly, the activity with which he places his practical abilities at their disposal. Of a new community one cannot say that it "does", "wants" or "requires" something – such formulations merely conceal the old, unfree collective consciousness. The new community lives from the good will of the individual, which in principle cannot be enforced. A shared effort toward a healthy social climate and a communicative style of work can, however, significantly support it. The decisive question, therefore, is how we must cooperate so that the creative forces of each individual co-worker can develop as freely as possible and at the same time in the service of the common task.

Self-Determination and Task

The independence of the individual in a community being newly formed must be linked to a definite task; otherwise it easily slides into playing on one's own little sandpile. A free school is certainly not an institution for the "self-realization" of teachers. It came into being because certain people set themselves the task of providing children with a different, better pedagogy. They devote their strength and abilities to this goal. An anthroposophical clinic arises because certain people see the need to expand medicine with new approaches and are willing to work for this. The awareness of a task and the sense of responsibility are transformed into concrete initiative, which must then still prove itself as the capacity for self-governing action in the everyday operation of the institution. The starting point is an understanding of the task in the sense of a shared vision which the people in the institution have worked out together.
A new community arises freely: individual people take up initiative. Others join them, because they see something meaningful in their initiative. This impulse becomes the basis of the profile of the institution. It then asserts itself in practical life, because people develop its impulse through their professional skills and continually grapple with it anew. At the same time it is open to anyone who regards this impulse as meaningful, and it does not require ideological agreement from them.
Self-determination, independence, self-government – this means taking on overall responsibility for the functioning of the institution, that is, for spiritual, legal and economic matters alike. It does not matter in which of these fields the institution sets its main goal – even in a free spiritual life we must deal with questions of law and economics. A Waldorf teacher who thinks he is responsible only for pedagogy and that the functioning of the school as a whole does not concern him does not act in a self-governing sense.
This indivisibility of responsibility for the whole does not, however, mean that there should be no division of labor. On the contrary, if everyone tries to arrange everything, in the end nothing gets arranged. When an individual has to ask everyone else before each practical step, what arises is not democracy but the dictatorship of the majority. It is appropriate for everyone within the community to have their own tasks, which they take on and by fulfilling which they help the whole. This applies not only to the individual who is responsible for their school class or for their department in a company, but also to all groups that take part in the self-governing process – for example, to the parents and teachers of a Waldorf school, who should regard one another as equal groups which of course play different roles and must mutually respect their differing areas of responsibility.

Seeking a Common Ground – Picture of the Task and Thinking Work

Many people experience self-government as a burden rather than the relief it should properly be. The reason is often a dysfunctional handing over and respecting of responsibility among colleagues. We experience conferences of the teachers' college or of co-workers as fruitless when we never reach the essential questions and instead drown in a multitude of minor problems.
How can we ensure the necessary division of labor, while at the same time preventing everyone from thinking only about the narrow area of their own responsibility? How can we arrange for the recognition of the decisive tasks and problems which the cooperating community faces? How can we master the forces which – from outside and from within – threaten the very essence of the community and its tasks?
This involves much more than questions of social techniques or the skilled leadership of a conversation. We will reach identification with the common task and secure the quality of the work only when we create space for shared spiritual work. One component of this is a shared diagnosis of the situation, the difficulties and the tasks. It consists in all participants in the conference together forming a coherent picture of the problem before them, and a consciousness of shared responsibility for its solution. It is not enough, however, to present the problems; they must also be looked at in the light of the essential impulses on which the community is founded – it is precisely here that fruitful concrete solutions begin to arise. The second component of shared spiritual work is therefore working with the basic ideas from which we proceed – for example, the shared study of some fundamental pedagogical text (or a text essential to the field in which we work).
When in this way it succeeds in recognizing a problem in time and clarifying the basic direction in which its solution should proceed, the concrete solution can – indeed must, where technically possible – be handed over to the responsibility of an individual. The initiative of the individual is based, on the one hand, on the awareness that he can actively take part in the basic idea of the community, and on the other hand, on the fact that he can work on his tasks on his own responsibility, without someone constantly telling him what to do. It is quite essential, however, that work on the basic idea of the community be carried on continuously, and not only afterwards, when practical decisions have already been made or when one of those involved has already begun to act on his own.

Delegating, Deciding, Carrying Out

The basic means that makes individual action on a shared basis possible is the principle of delegation. By this we do not mean the authoritarian assignment of tasks, where the execution is subject to detailed instructions and constant control, but the granting of mandates to individuals or groups who then work on the task for a certain period on their own responsibility. Whoever is delegated in this way acts individually, and yet in the name and for the benefit of the whole community.
It is extremely important to handle the process of delegation consciously. Hardly anything endangers the functioning of a self-governing community more than a confused and insufficiently conscious transfer of responsibility. This most easily happens in cases where no one actively volunteers to take on the task, so that everyone is glad when at last at least someone is found. Conscious delegation, by contrast, means that we jointly and clearly describe the task and ask who can be entrusted with its independent fulfilment. We must take care here to avoid two pitfalls. The first is the already mentioned delegation of tasks without regard to the abilities of the person concerned. The second is the emergence of a group of experienced people who, in the community's opinion, can manage everything and who as a matter of course take on all the tasks – this leads both to their overload and to younger colleagues being unable to gather experience and develop their abilities. The essential prerequisite for conscious handling of delegation is a collegial climate in which criticism is not taken personally from either side, and in which shortcomings are discussed in such a way that, looking at them, possibilities for further development arise.
It is essential that the community, once it has clarified the general points of view regarding the problem and its solution, again withdraws into the background and leaves the working out of the concrete solution to the delegated persons. On them should rest – insofar as this is possible in the given case – also the decision itself that the worked-out solution will be carried out. An attempt to decide everything in the conference paralyzes initiative, blocks the decision-making process and leads to a constant squandering of the most precious resource – time. Fundamentally, this is an expression of distrust toward the individual, whom we deprive of a real mandate to solve the problem by constantly interfering.
We take it as a matter of course that the freedom of the delegated person consists in the possibility of choosing the way in which the assumed task is solved, and not in the possibility of ceasing to concern oneself with the task. Equally self-evident is that the mandate may have the most varied scope. In a fundamental decision about the life of the school – for example concerning the construction of a new school building – it will not be the teachers' college alone that decides, but the parents' association and other bodies will also be involved in the decision-making. The task delegated to a smaller group in this case would consist in preparing the basis for such a major decision.
However, in delegating responsibility it must never be merely a matter of drawing up non-binding proposals which the remaining members of the community, who did not concern themselves with the matter at all, may then criticize merely on the basis of their superficial impressions. A community that allowed this would soon be overcome by incompetence, and its competent members by frustration, through which only few would pass far enough to be willing ever again to take on any task.
The concrete carrying out of what has been worked out and decided must in any case again rest with the delegated individual or group. The conference of teachers or co-workers has primarily an advisory role, not an executive one.

The Call for Accountability and Discharge

The process of delegating responsibility to an individual or group is not complete as long as the delegating community does not again take this responsibility back from the delegated persons. After a clearly defined period of time, the community again consciously looks at the area in which responsibility was delegated and takes back its overall responsibility for this area. To the delegated persons, at the end of their mandate, we grant "discharge" – that is, we release them from responsibility, relieve them of their constant connection with their former task, and let them know that the results of their work have been accepted and that they now have free hands again for other tasks.
The handing over of responsibility to the delegated persons and their return to the whole community are the foundation of a healthy rhythm in the self-governing life of the institution. For responsibility for the whole arises out of one's own responsibility for the individual delegated task and its solution, and the handing over and taking back of responsibility makes this connection conscious. When a delegated person presents the results of their work to the community, it is not an authoritarian call to account, but an opportunity to open up to others the area of their responsibility and to explain their work to them. For the others it is a reason for gratitude for the solving of the task taken on. Giving account of the work on a delegated task can thus be a truly festive occasion. If every member of a working collective has at least once a year the opportunity to speak about their work, this heals the social climate. If, on the other hand, a co-worker has the impression that others do not see and do not value their work, this worsens relationships throughout their working environment.

Dynamic Delegation

We have described seven steps – forming a shared picture, working on basic ideas, delegating, deciding, carrying out, giving account, and discharge – which can be summed up in the single concept of "dynamic delegation", in which we can see the decisive instrument of responsible collegial leadership of an independent institution. Dynamic delegation connects shared and individual steps in the work and life of the organization. In the sense of the motto of social ethics cited above, we could say that forming a shared picture, working on basic ideas, giving account and discharge are the processes through which the community forms itself "in the mirror of the human soul". Between them lie the independent delegating, deciding and carrying out. These are the steps in which the community steps into the background and the "power of the individual soul" is at work.
Rich experience in the field of self-governing communities has already shown that ignoring this rhythm does not pay. Wherever the community as a whole tries to solve tasks that should be taken up by an individual, or wherever an individual does what the community should do, the community becomes sick and ceases to fulfil its tasks.

Related articles

On the Relationship of Marriage to the Word

Download as PDF version The wedding, or the Sacrament of Marriage, is the last sacrament in the whole organism of sacraments, for some time after the wedding a child usually is…

Read more