SEVEN STEPS OF RESURRECTION

THE SEVEN STEPS OF THE RESURRECTION

The biblical accounts of the resurrection are very diverse. Not only do the different Gospels tell different stories about it, but they sometimes describe the same event quite differently. The most striking example is the event that took place early in the morning on the third day after Christ’s death, namely the first visit of the women to the tomb, where they heard, in their encounter with an angel or angels, the message of the resurrection. We would have to speak here of four entirely different stories that share only the basic framework: a visit by a woman or women to the tomb. This has led many to conclude that the whole story must be invented, or at least that we simply know nothing precise about it. Yet we always approach it from the standpoint of modern people, who would most gladly watch a documentary film to find out how everything “really” happened. The Gospels will most likely not fulfil this wish, but we have another possibility: we can read the various accounts without preconceptions and let them work on us with the question of what they can tell us about the resurrection. We will then discover, with surprise, that they tell us a great deal. It turns out that in the seemingly random sequence of the Gospels, as well as in the number and temporal order of the events described, there is a certain order that leads us closer to an understanding of the resurrection.

The Empty Tomb

If we read the accounts of the events of Easter morning in the order in which they appear one after another in the four Gospels, it seems that each captures a different, successive moment of the overall event. In Matthew’s account, the women come to the tomb while it is still dark, at the moment when an earthquake rolls away the stone from the entrance of the tomb. In this event, a majestic angelic being appears to the women; it itself causes the earthquake and opens the tomb. Its appearance resembles lightning and snow, and it seems to be at home in everything that happens in nature. It announces the resurrection to the women. In Mark’s account, the event has progressed a little further. The stone has been rolled away and the sun is just rising. The angel who announces the resurrection to the women is described as a young man, as if he represented the power of the dawning day, of a new beginning. In Luke’s Gospel we hear for the first time that the women enter the tomb and seek Jesus, but do not find him there. They are perplexed, and then two angels, described as men, appear to them and announce the resurrection. Significantly, however, they urge them: “Remember how he told you!” This is a further step compared with Mark, a step inward. Luke then already hints at what only the Evangelist John describes in detail. After the women—in John’s account only Mary Magdalene—report to the disciples what has happened at the tomb, Peter and the disciple whom Jesus loved run to the tomb to see everything with their own eyes. And now John describes what can actually be seen: the body of Jesus is no longer in the tomb; only the linen cloths in which it had been wrapped remain, while the cloth that had covered the face lies somewhat apart. John adds that the disciple sees all of this and believes. This is remarkable, for he believes when faced with emptiness, with absence.
Thus the four Gospels lead us ever closer to the heart of the matter, to the empty tomb. But the tomb is not completely empty. The linen cloths remain, which means that no one carried away Jesus’ body—for they would have taken it along with the cloths—but the body has, in a still unknown way, as it were dissolved and disappeared from the cloths. We may call this fact the first encounter with the Risen One. At first it is entirely incomprehensible. But how could it be otherwise? For something happened that surpassed all human experience of the time. Until then no human being had risen from the dead, and the Gospel emphasizes that such a resurrection necessarily involves the dissolution of the bodily remains down to the last grain of dust. We should not think that the Risen One still resembles a human being as we commonly know one. Evidently only this radical presupposition opens up the possibility of a true understanding. This is the message of John’s Gospel.

The other Gospels each add yet another perspective. Matthew indicates that the resurrection is an event concerning the whole earth. Just as on Good Friday, at the hour of Jesus’ death, an earthquake tore the temple veil and opened a view into the holiest sanctuary, so at the hour of his resurrection a view opens into the empty tomb as into a new temple sanctuary. And Matthew also says that events like the shaking of the earth, which seem merely material, nevertheless have their causes in a world inhabited by spiritual hierarchies. Spirit reigns also within matter. Mark points to the rising sun and emphasizes the dawn of a new creation. Luke indicates that the resurrection is nothing accidental. The whole life of Christ was directed toward that end, which both he himself and the ancient prophets had foretold. Perhaps we can finally say, in the spirit of John’s Gospel, that the empty tomb is the meaning of human history, in whose centre the Word became flesh, in order to transform it into a new body. We shall see that the motifs indicated here are further developed in the subsequent encounters with the Risen One.

The Gardener

We find the further accounts mainly in the Gospels of Luke and John. Matthew and Mark omit them or merely hint at them. That is why we will keep mainly to Luke and John. After Peter and the disciple whom Jesus loved had returned home, only Mary Magdalene remained at the tomb (according to John). She has not yet understood what has happened and gives way to her grief. She sits before the burial chamber where Jesus’ body had been laid, leans into it and weeps. She cannot help thinking that someone has carried away her master. Then two angels appear to her; they are seated where the linen cloths lie: one where Jesus’ head had been, and one where his feet had been. By their position they show that something like an invisible trace, a kind of spiritual imprint, remained after Jesus’ body. The angels ask her why she is weeping. Their question draws Mary’s attention and presence of mind. She is able to turn her gaze away from the place of sorrow and toward the light. Outside, in the sunshine, she sees a figure whom she takes to be the gardener.

At first glance it seems that this image offers itself naturally, since the tomb lies in the middle of a garden. But precisely this designation says much more than a mere matter of course. First of all, it points out that the Risen One looks different from the Jesus with whom the disciples and women had travelled. And why does he appear in the form of a gardener and not, for example, in the form of a king or high priest? We might describe the gardener as an assistant of the sun, who ensures that various plants take good root in the earth, grow toward the sun and thus bring forth a proper harvest. He is a guardian of life on earth. Here we see that the motif of the rising sun, emphasized by Mark, is further developed. The gardener asks Mary why she weeps and whom she is seeking, and she—supposing that he may have carried her master away—begs him to tell her where. Then Jesus addresses her by name, and she recognizes him. From all that we know of Mary’s life and her relationship to Christ, we understand that the power which led her to recognize the Risen One is love, the love of a human being who has experienced on herself the grace that leads to new life.

The Breaking of Bread

The next event in time is the journey of two disciples to Emmaus, described by Luke. These two disciples are in great doubt about what has happened. The various incidents surrounding Jesus’ death and the reports of his supposed resurrection confuse them, so that they do not know what to think of it all. They are on the road, when someone joins them and asks about everything with such interest, as if he knew nothing at all. They therefore have to recall everything in detail and bring up from their souls what they know. And this again gives the stranger the opportunity to remind them of various words from the Holy Scriptures that speak of Christ, his death and his resurrection. Gradually a new order forms in their minds, so that they begin to understand. Yet they still do not know who it is that is speaking with them.

This time the guiding motive of the encounter with the Risen One is not the disciples’ love for their master, although this is not excluded, but the search for inner certainty: to what extent one can trust the various reports and what they actually mean. The precondition for this certainty is a certain, though initial, degree of understanding and knowing, which here arises from remembrance. The soul must free itself from the limitations of earthly space and time and connect events and statements from different spatial and temporal horizons into a new whole. Then it can grasp something of the supratemporal and supraspatial nature of the Risen One. This we may call faith. At the end of their journey the two disciples have a clear feeling that their present doubts will soon dissolve within them and that the certainty they seek will be given to them. Out of this feeling they beg the unknown companion to stay with them, and when they eat together he takes bread, gives thanks, breaks it and gives it to them. Seeing how he does this, the disciples remember that they had already seen these hands before, holding bread with immense inner clarity and at the same time love—and they recognize him. The impression of the Risen One becomes connected for them with the memory of Christ, who had earlier wandered with them on earth. Thus they are able to recognize him. Knowing and faith here complement and strengthen each other. In this story Luke develops further the motif that he himself had introduced in the encounter of the women with the empty tomb.

The Giver of Peace

At the end of the same day the Risen One appeared to all eleven apostles. Mark describes this in the longer ending of his Gospel, and Luke and John likewise. In the last one, however, Thomas is missing. Let us keep to John’s account, which places emphasis on a special point. According to him, the Risen One came into the room where the disciples were, although the doors were shut. He greets them with the words: “Peace be with you.” And at the same time he shows them his hands and side, that is, the wounds of the crucifixion. At first this is puzzling. The body of the Risen One evidently is not subject to the laws of earthly matter. It can enter a closed space. But precisely the wounds of the crucifixion were originally traces on a material body, which of course remained even after death. John indicates a paradox here. The body of the Risen One is not the body the disciples knew, and yet it is closely connected with the earlier visible body, for it bears its wounds. It carries the traces of a martyr’s death, which means that this death is an inseparable part of the new life; it is its foundation and presupposition. Or, put differently: the new life is the fruit of that death and would not be possible at all without it.

The paradox that John indicates here is the same as in the case of the empty tomb: connection and at the same time otherness. For such phenomena we have the concept of metamorphosis. Something is the same, yet appears in a different form, like a caterpillar, a chrysalis and a butterfly, which by their outer form we would also not judge to be the same creature. Matthias Grünewald, the creator of the Isenheim Altarpiece, painted the Risen One on it in the same form that every human being has, but he painted him as though the body rising from the tomb had no weight and gave off a subtle light. Five clearly visible wounds on the hands, feet and side shine in particular. The impression of weightlessness and light is intensified by the cloth that flows freely around the body and shines in all colours. Grünewald depicted the body of the Risen One in a familiar form, yet in a weightless and luminous metamorphosis: connection and at the same time otherness.

John further says that the disciples rejoiced. How could it be otherwise, when he who had died nevertheless lives? But the joy of the disciples is even deeper. It is connected precisely with the metamorphosis of Christ’s body, for death has thereby lost, as the apostle Paul says, its sting. It can be meaningfully built into the foundations of the new life. The life lived so far will have, although we must die, a connection with the life to come. The fruits of earthly life will not be lost, but will continue to exist in a certain transformation. This is also the meaning of the next statement of Christ. He repeats the greeting, “Peace be with you,” and then gives the disciples, with the breath of the Holy Spirit, full authority over human sins. They are given the power to forgive or retain sins. The meaning of precisely this statement is disputed, but we can clarify it with examples.
Mark and Luke relate in their Gospels the story of four men who bring a paralysed man on a stretcher so that Jesus may heal him, but cannot get into the house. So they lower the sick man inside through an opening in the roof. When Jesus sees this, he says to the man: “Your sins are forgiven you.” But the Pharisees begin to reflect on whether this is not blasphemy, since only God can forgive sins. Then Jesus reminds them that the precondition of healing is the forgiveness of sins, and that the Son of Man has the power to do this on earth. As proof of this, he heals the paralysed man. The paralysed man had evidently suffered much during his illness and had undergone an inner transformation that removed the psychological causes of his paralysis. Thus his sins can be forgiven. Another example, which John describes, is the woman caught in adultery. According to the Law of Moses she was condemned to death by stoning. But in response to the questions of the Pharisees, Jesus says nothing about it and only writes with his finger in the earth. Only after further insistence does he say briefly that the one who is without sin should throw the first stone. There is undoubtedly no one like that, and so in the end no one condemns the woman—not even Christ. He only says gravely: “Go and sin no more.” It is clear that the woman, who has just barely escaped death, at that moment enters the path of inner transformation, on which she will be accompanied by the strength radiating from the memory of her encounter with Christ. This strength will help her to hold back the inclination toward similar deeds. The sin is loosened. At the end of what may be a long path, the woman will be a new person.

The Risen One hands on to the disciples a power that can help people in two ways on the path toward inner transformation. Whoever receives this power can be at peace with his life and with the outer world. Everything can ultimately serve the growth of spiritual forces in the human soul, whether they are pains, illnesses or one’s own mistakes. This is the message of the fourth encounter with the Risen One. Looking back at the first four encounters, we can see in them indications of four parts of the sacrament of the altar. The encounter with the angels at the empty tomb is, in the true sense of the word, the gospel, the joyful message from angelic lips. In the encounter of Mary Magdalene with the gardener we find an indication of the offering. She must turn her gaze away from the world of sorrow and death, in order to behold in the light the giver of life. The two disciples on the road to Emmaus experience an inner transformation and the transformation of bread in the hands of the Risen One. And the evening encounter of Christ with the eleven disciples, mediating peace and the strength of inner transformation, has the character of communion. Thus we see that the sequence of events, as the Gospels tell them to us, is not accidental, but is a reflection of higher, spiritual laws.

“My Lord and My God!”

According to John’s Gospel, Thomas was not present at the previous encounter, and when the other disciples told him about it, he did not believe. Evidently he told himself that the life of the soul and spirit after death is nothing special; only if the body has risen from the grave is it something new, something that has not yet happened. The wounds were to be the proof of this. After eight days the Risen One appears again, and this time Thomas is present too. Christ invites him to truly touch his wounds with his hand. Then Thomas exclaims: “My Lord and my God!” It seems that at that moment he has an experience deeper than what the other disciples had known so far, and that with the touch of Christ’s wounds an experience of his divinity is connected for him. What, then, do the wounds actually mean?

Today a human being has a closed circulation of the blood, which gives him the experience of an independent, self-contained personality. This experience is very important, but at the same time it is the source of all egoism. We indeed cannot shed our blood, for that would mean our death. As long as a human being lives on earth, he must have a closed circulation, otherwise he is ill. And he must also be to a certain degree egoistic. Christ, however, shed his blood on the cross and thereby also overcame egoism. His wounds became, as it were, gates between the inner being of man and the world. When Thomas now experiences all this, he feels how egoism departs from him, how in his soul he dies into Christ. It is a profound mystical experience of the new human being, who has regained the paradisal innocence. Thomas here is a prototype of all mystics who did not want merely to believe in Christ, but wanted to taste him as God in their own soul.

The Miraculous Catch of Fish

The last chapter of John’s Gospel at first glance seems to be a narrative about an event that has all the marks of earthly, sensory reality. The place is clear: the Sea of Galilee; the participants are likewise clear: Peter and six other disciples. It is also clear what they are doing: they want to catch fish. Only at the end of the story are some things unusual, for example that it is enough to cast the net on the other side of the boat, and suddenly there is a great number of fish. But the main peculiarity is that Peter had been naked the whole night, and when he heard that the Lord was standing on the shore, he put on his cloak and threw himself into the water. That is how we read it, word for word. If we add that, according to Luke, the disciples remained in Jerusalem until the feast of Pentecost, we run into a contradiction that requires deeper reflection. And this may lead us to the thought that the miraculous catch is not an external event, but an inner experience, which is nevertheless no less real. Let us try to read it as a pictorial account of an inner, spiritual encounter with the Risen One.

The image that John uses captures very well the situation of a person who is preparing for sleep. The psychic-spiritual core of the human being each evening “pushes off” from the “shore” of daily consciousness and “sails” out into the depths of the spiritual world, as if in a boat. The sleep of the people of that time was not as hard and unconscious as ours, and often a person brought from it living memories—“fish.” The disciples evidently prepared together for the “catch” (perhaps through a common prayer or remembrance), but this time they apparently fail to catch anything. When the day is already drawing near, they approach the “shore,” the awakening. “There,” in the world of daily consciousness, stands Jesus—the Risen One—but they do not recognize him. He invites them to cast the net on the “right” side of the boat. They are not to wait passively until something rises from the depths, but to activate the inner being—and at once the net is full. As soon as Peter hears that it is the Lord, he wants to reach the “shore”—to awaken. The psychic-spiritual core of our being is “naked” at night; it leaves the body and must “clothe” itself again in the morning. With Jesus’ help the disciples now succeed in “drawing the net to the shore,” that is, in preserving the experiences of the night until the moment of waking. In this atmosphere of living memory of nightly spiritual experiences, and in the freshness of the morning, the Risen One celebrates with the disciples the sacrament of communion. This is an important complement to the Last Supper, from which strength comes through the presence of the Risen One. Here, on a higher level, the breaking of bread in the house of the two disciples at Emmaus is repeated. In this morning experience on the “shore of the sea,” together with the commission given to Peter to tend the sheep that follows, we can see the seed of the future Christian priesthood.

The Ascension

Luke writes in the Acts of the Apostles that for forty days the Lord showed himself to the disciples in many ways as the Risen One, and taught them the mysteries of the Kingdom of God. From this it follows that there were more encounters besides the empty tomb than the five that the Gospels bring close to us. Luke himself, for example, indicates that the Risen One also appeared to Peter on the first day, but he did not develop this indication further. Thus it may seem that the selection of events is rather accidental. Yet looking back at all the encounters as a whole, a higher law becomes apparent, even though the various encounters are distributed among different Gospels. The empty tomb is the only thing that can be seen with bodily eyes. Yet the Risen One is not in it. One can meet him, led by love, in the realm of life, as Mary Magdalene beheld him, or, led by an urgent question through living memory, in the realm of the soul, as the disciples at Emmaus experienced him. Among the whole circle of disciples he appeared as the one who gives the strength to transform destiny, which is the capacity of the human I. Thomas then experienced the beginning of the mystical union with Christ, an experience that leads the human soul to the threshold of life and death, to the touch of the spirit. The miraculous catch of fish finally enables the disciples present not only to receive the gifts of the Risen One themselves, but also to mediate them to people and to awaken in them a new, higher life.

There still remains a seventh step—the Ascension. At first glance it seems that this last step of the Risen One is a step away from the disciples and thus away from human beings altogether. Mark writes (according to the longer ending) that he was taken up and sat down at the right hand of God. Luke says that he disappeared from the disciples’ sight and was carried up to heaven, and in the Acts of the Apostles he adds that a cloud hid him from their eyes. This took place on the Mount of Olives. Only Matthew, who places the last encounter on a mountain in Galilee, emphasizes that the Risen One will remain with them until the end of this age and that all creative power in heaven and on earth has been given to him.
When we hear today the word heaven, we usually imagine something indefinite upward, some more or less empty space, but it has almost completely faded from consciousness that it is in fact a different quality of being. Only expressions such as “heavenly fragrance, heavenly beauty or heavenly peace” dimly remind us of this other level. The heavenly level of being is the level of creative forces, of beauty and of the true meaning of all visible things, and it is not somewhere far away, but only hidden behind the surface perceptible to the senses. We might also say that it is the spiritual or divine level. And this does not act only in nature, but also in the sphere of human culture. The heavens reveal themselves wherever true science, true art, true religion and true social relations between people are cultivated. The word “true” here means something that draws its strength from a living relationship to the spirit. Into that sphere the Risen One has “departed.” As the confession of the Community of Christians says: he became the lord of the heavenly powers on earth. He does not wish to reveal himself only to a chosen group of disciples, but to all people, and he wishes to act, in the sense of the original divine forces, for the progress of the whole world. He founded the kingdom of the spirit, or the kingdom of heaven, on earth. He became the Spirit of the Earth.

We now have before us the whole course of Christ’s resurrection. Before the dawn of Easter morning the earth shook, and a new human being rose from the grave. At the end of his path the Risen One united with the heavenly forces on earth, so that the new human being might become the world—and the world the new human being. This is the heavenly wedding, the sacred goal of earthly history, of which the Apocalypse speaks. Christ made it possible through his resurrection.

Frank Peschel
from the magazine OKRUH A STŘED 1/2004

Related articles

On the Relationship of Marriage to the Word

Download as PDF version The wedding, or the Sacrament of Marriage, is the last sacrament in the whole organism of sacraments, for some time after the wedding a child usually is…

Read more